Thanks for the report jgriffith91786!
Unfortunately, the game log seems not to support your description of events. Did you do any undo which may have 'overwritten' that problematic event?
From the game log, fiercelord played a Wishing Well on his turn 14, wishing for Plunder and finding it. At this time, he had Plunders in his hand, and when I replayed it and chose Plunder in my hand, it worked (registered as Plunder).
On turn 15, turtle01 played Wishing Well 3 times in a row, wishing for Encampment each time (never finding it, though
). But in this case, that player had 2 Encampments in hand, not Plunders.
As far as I can see from scanning the log, those were the only times that Plunder or Encampment where wished for.
I also made a new bot game where I tried to recreate the situation, and again, I could wish for a Plunder that I clicked on in my hand.
I'm not sure what happened, or did I overlook some other play you are referring to?