Login  |  Register

Author Topic: Issue with Pillage card (read details)  (Read 457 times)

Offline refugee

  • Unconfirmed
  • *
  • Posts: 2
    • View Profile
Issue with Pillage card (read details)
« on: 24 July 2019, 12:45:36 AM »
Playing Definition of Pillage:

Trash this. Each other player with 5 or more cards in hand reveals his hand and discards a card that you choose. Gain 2 Spoils from the Spoils pile.

In Game execution:
Had Pillage on my hand. Ended my buy round with buying Farmland (When you buy this, trash a card from your hand. Gain a card costing exactly $2 more than the trashed card). Used Farmland to trash Pillage and when I did so I got nothing in return. It should have given me at least 2x Spoils - which I wanted.

The card does not say you need to play it first.

Seems something is off.

Online Ingix

  • Global Moderator
  • *****
  • Posts: 1852
    • View Profile
Re: Issue with Pillage card (read details)
« Reply #1 on: 24 July 2019, 09:55:51 AM »
You have a misconception about how things work in Dominion. That misconception is kinda 'common'. Players think about trashing the Pillage (or Embargo, or Feast) as the 'cost' of their respective effects, so when that trashing happens any other way, they think they are entitled to the effect. But that's not how it works.

From a game-balancing point the trashing might have been considered a balancing measure for the effect. Consider at one hand Feast, which costs $4 and gains you a card costing up to $5, but trashes itself in the process.  OTOH there is Artisan, which also gains you a card costing up $5, but doesn't trash itself. It costs $6. It's clear that the trashing of Feast is meant to balance it only costing $4. From a design perspective, the trashing of Feast may be a cost, but from a rules perspective, it is just an effect.

Back to the actual question: the default for any text on an Action card is that it applies when you play the card. If it applies to anything else, it will specifically mention it, under a dividing line.

Take for example a look at Cultist.

That card lets you draw 3 cards when you trash it, for example with Farmland. But note that it specifially mentions this condition ("When you trash this") and it is put under a dividing line, to make sure players understand that it is a separate ability, and not related to the "on-play" effect (draw 2 cards + more).

Your argument

The card does not say you need to play it first.

is backwards. You need to provide a reason why you think you should follow instructions on a card. Otherwise, why not follow the instructions on Smithy anytime it is in your hand (without playing it)?

The reason you are giving is incorrect, because it is not based on any rule given anywhere. There is no rule that says "If a card's text starts with a certain effect, and that effect happens in the game by whatever means, you are allowed to continue to execute the remainder of that card's text."