Text only | Text with Images

Shuffle iT Forum

Dominion => Bug Reports => Card Bugs => Topic started by: 4est on 10 September 2017, 12:08:30 AM

Title: Sacrificing Inherited Estate Results in only 2VP and no +2 Cards +2 Actions
Post by: 4est on 10 September 2017, 12:08:30 AM
Unless I'm mistaken, I believe Inherited Estates are Action-Victory cards and when trashed with Sacrifice should result in +2 VP, and +2 Cards +2 Actions; similar to Sacrificing Mill or Nobles.  Yet, in the below game I only received 2 VP. 

Game ID: 6719851
Decision: 193

Thanks for looking into this!

4est
Title: Re: Sacrificing Inherited Estate Results in only 2VP and no +2 Cards +2 Actions
Post by: kingdedede on 10 September 2017, 08:13:33 PM
I think it's correct. Sacrifice checks the card's type after you trash it (since the "trash a card" text is before the "if it's an action/treasure/victory" text). The Estate is no longer yours when it's in the trash, so it's just an Estate.
Title: Re: Sacrificing Inherited Estate Results in only 2VP and no +2 Cards +2 Actions
Post by: 4est on 11 September 2017, 06:44:23 PM
Ah, that makes sense.  And I remember now other rare cases when this same rule (an Estate is no longer yours when it's in the trash, so it's just an Estate) has come up for other cards.  Looks like I was mistaken after all and the client has it correct.

Thanks!
Text only | Text with Images