Hamlet-Watchtower-Tunnel bug?

[blueblimp]

If you have a Hamlet, Watchtower, and Tunnel in hand, you should be able to do this:

Play Hamlet.
Discard Tunnel for +1 action, revealing Tunnel to gain a Gold, revealing Watchtower to put the Gold on top of your deck.
Discard Watchtower for +1 buy.

However, in the current UI the behavior is:

Play Hamlet.
Select "both" to discard two cards.
Select Tunnel and Watchtower.
Reveal Tunnel to gain a Gold. There is no prompt to reveal Watchtower, so you can't topdeck the Gold.

This happens because the Hamlet UI does not really follow the card rules, where each discard is a separate step. Instead it asks:
Discard for Action
Discard for Buy
Both
Don't Discard

(I'd suggest prompting as follows to adhere to the rules and still be reasonably convenient:

First prompt:
Discard for Action
Discard for Buy
Don't Discard

Second prompt, only appears if you selected "Discard for Action":
Discard for Buy
Don't Discard

So if you want to discard twice, you can pick Discard for Action the first time, then Discard for Buy the second time.)

[tufftaeh]

As the discard options on Hamlet are two separate effects, this is indeed a bug in the new client. DXV has confirmed that you can react separately: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=1004.msg15441#msg15441.

So for full compliance with the rules the client needs to do/have one of these:

• discard the first selected card first implicitly (still allowing to react with the second selected card), or
• an ordering box after [Both] (discard the left card first, still allowing to react with the right card), or
• separate steps for [Discard for +Action]/[No Discard for +Action] and then [Discard for +Buy]/[No Discard for +Buy].

With any variant, the direct click on a green-bordered action card could still be used for [No more Discard for this Tunnel].

With the current card set, the ordering box is only required if a Tunnel and the only Watchtower in hand are selected. Actually, to make it easier, the Tunnel could be always discarded first automatically, I guess, even if that would technically be stealing a decision from the player.