Messages

I agree. I'm 99% sure that there were many specific error messages for diffferent kinds of problems at one time, but some change made only the dreaded "internal error" message be  displayed to players.

That game has Shaman.

+1 Action
+$1

You may trash a card from your hand.
In games using this, at the start of your turn, gain a card from the trash costing up to $6.

It's very normal that Estates get trashed by a player with Shaman and that the "In games using this" effect has the other player gain the Estates. While you normally have a choice which card to gain from the trash (and get asked about that by dominion.games), if there is only one card in the trash you have no choice and will gain it automatically if there is no other "start of turn" efffect.

That's why it's very plausible that you have 4 Estates (or even more) without ever concsiously gaining one after your initial 3. It was an automatic effect by dominion.games (which in this case obscured the fact that you gained an Estate).

In Shaman games I usually have the trash permanently open, to see what cards await me.

[not gained]

What happened was correct. Note that Trader got errata some years ago use the exchange mechanic for the reaction efffect:

Trash a card from your hand. Gain a Silver per $1 it costs.
When you gain a card, you may reveal this from your hand, to exchange the card for a Silver.

A card that comes into your possession via an exchange is not gained, so no effects that trigger on gaining (like from Rapid Expansion) happen. The rule was spelled out in the Adventures rule book (which introduced the exchange mechanic for the Travelers):



and is also noted in the updated Hinterlands rulebook in the description for Trader.

What you say is correct, Rice should give at least 3 coins in that secanario, as the types among your card include at least Action, Attack and Treasure.

The game can't be loaded, so it looks like something did indeed go wrong there.

In turn 17 you gained a Border Village with Tools, and for the cheaper card that comes with Border Village you chose Duchy.

__pez__: Done
jimpix : Done

Done!

I'm not sure if there are undos involved, but the only time in the game where Continue was followed by playing and gaining a Wayfarer, no Silver was gained.

But I know that the implementation of "Return to your Action phase" has an incorrect timing on dominion.games, so it seems plausible that the Silver gain is handled incorrectly with regard to Footpad.

Normally this problem is quickly fixed, but the number of people who can fix it is small, so if several of them are not online at the time it happens (like for when you posted), it takes longer. It was unfortunately such a case where it took > 1h 😒.

Yes, that was unfortunate series of events that lead to the "waste" of the Abundace effect for you. Abundance will trigger on the very next gain of an Action card, which could also be on your opponent's turn (like with a card giving you a Ruin).

@gadfly221: Done

@Kjellerbryggern: Done

The line means a Search that was removed from play this turn will stop functioning later. It isn't talking about other Searches played afterwards.

If it left play due to a pile becoming empty, than the line is not saying anything you didn't know before. It shouldn't really be there in that case. If Search left play for some other reason (usually with something like Way of the Horse when played using a Throne Room), the line reminds you it will no longer have its normal effect on later turns.

Yes, it might be a bit confusing. But you just played an Miser with an Elder, so you should roughly know what to expect. Note that you when you have clicked one buttton, the other stays as before (so still clickable).

Other cards with intrinsicsally more than one choice have updated the "Done Choosing" button to "X+", where x is the normal amount of coices for the card, implementing that for Miser etc. should be doable.

If you get this message, it's a reboot problem on one server. As soon as the dev is informed, they will correct the problem. Best way to do report the problem is via Discord, as it's much easier to keep track of new massages and vastly more people lurk there (and can inform the dev or some other people that can correct the problem) are here on the forum. I usually check the forum 2-3 times a day, which is not enough to catch this type of problem with any regularity.

All done for gdogwildin, JordanWeistein and Tohtori Ripulius!